What does it mean when my car is declared a total loss?
How does my insurance determine that my vehicle is a total loss?
Every insurance company is different, just as each state is different. There are two different ways that insurance companies determine the value of your car.
The first is what’s called a “Total Loss Threshold” – you can find the threshold for each state here. The total loss threshold is the point at which the insurance company is legally required to declare the vehicle a total loss and apply for a salvage title for the vehicle. There are 28 states who have individually chosen a threshold; some are at 100% like Colorado and Texas, others are lower like 75% in New York. This is a legally required maximum threshold percentage; meaning the insurance company can pick a lower threshold percentage and declare your vehicle a total loss at the percentage of their choosing, as long as it does not exceed the state mandated percentage. For instance, in CO our threshold is at 100%, but some insurance companies will declare a vehicle totaled at the salvage value of 40% – that’s 60% of your car’s worth we’re leaving out.
The other 22 states, like Hawaii, who do not have specific percentages set for the total loss threshold, use a “Total Loss Formula” to determine the value of the vehicle. This is determined by totaling the cost of repairs and the salvage value of the vehicle. If that total equals or is higher than the actual cash value of your vehicle (before the damage occurred, of course), your car will be deemed a total loss. If the total cost of repairs plus your salvage value is less than the actual cash value, you should be able to have the repairs covered by your insurance company.
There are many insurance companies who insure drivers in different states, and who doesn’t love a good road trip across the borderlines? For these reasons, a lot of insurance companies have a set percentage for their total loss threshold lower than what states mandate. This way, no matter where the damage or accident occurs – down the street or across state lines – the company policy is the same. When I buy my next car and reevaluate insurance companies, I’m definitely going to be asking about the threshold – are you?


